This is the third article on GDPR, the first dealt with Brexit and GDPR, the second confirmation that UK will be implementing stronger Data Protection.
Complications
There may be some “gotchas”, possible “flies-in-the-ointment”; the question of adequacy due to differences in equivalence and the effects of divergence.
Equivalence – EU GDPR
Overtime, you get divergence in any system if there isn’t a common control factor. Which is likely to test compatibility in the future, but for now, more importantly, what will 2019 bring us ?
The Supervisory Authority enforces the GDPR (and DPA98), the European Court of Justice (CJEU) has the final say. Post-Brexit, this is unlikely to be the case and will likely be the UK’s Supreme Court.
There are other UK laws, such a Regulation of Investigatory Powers Act (RIPA) 2000 which are not compatible with the current EU directive, so are not going to work in harmony with GDPR. GDPR allows investigations for crimes, RIPA’s definition are looser.
There is also a political element too, will the other 27 EU member countries be generous in their assessment of UK Data Protection 2019 and grant her equivalence with a few choice derogations ?
So what’s going to happen?
No one knows for sure – this is my take on it :
UK (and globally others) will have to comply with EU GDPR, by May 2018 (it’s actually in force now, but not enforced till May 2018, EU 95/46/EC was repealed in April 2016).
Post-Brexit UK businesses will have to comply with UK GDPR and EU GDPR.
What happens to the contentious bits of UK law or UK interpretation / implementation ?
UK will have to negotiate acceptance of her derogations or compromise on some aspects of internal laws.
Without this, we will not have equivalence, which may lead to data processed in another more compliant EEA member state instead, which is something we’d all prefer to avoid.
… next article
More practical aspect of GDRP – How to approach GDPR and towards the goal of compliance